🗞️ In The News

• 🥤 PepsiCo's $2B Poppi Purchase: Anyone Care To Tell Me WTF a Prebiotic Soda Is? (Marketing Dive)

• 🌟 Meta’s New Ad Ratings – Putin’s Ads For Trump Pull in 5 Stars (Meta)

• 📻️ Podcasting Peaks: 210 Million Americans Tuning In Like Never Before (PodNews)

• 🤳 Perplexity Proposes TikTok Take Over – And Your Best Researcher Just Got Dumber (TheVerge)

🔗 Large On LinkedIn

• 😵 The Death of The Company Blog - From John James (link)

• 🤖 AI vs. The Power of Bureaucracy - From Tom Goodwin (link)

• 📎 The Power of a Good Brief - From Dan White (link)

• 🔍️ The Mental Jujitsu on AI Search - From Rand Fishkin (link)

💼 Case Studies: Case Closed

• 🚗 Uber’s Referral Program: The 12x ROI Growth Engine Every Business Wants (ViralLoops)

• 🗺️ Roadmaps Are Useless If No One Sees Them – How To Share Yours Right (TheGood)

• 📨 How To Optimise That Stale Email Sequence (CopyHackers)

🧰 You Won’t Blame These Tools

• 🖼️ Pika - Ditch Illustrator and create beautiful mockups with an easy builder.

• 🤳 Kive - Use AI to make gorgeous product photos.

• 👀 AttentionInsight - See how consumers engage with your designs before the launch.

• 🔎 Strella - AI-moderated interviews and instant synthesis, powering smarter and faster decisions.

WHY PRODUCT-MARKET FIT DAZZLES 🤩 

Once upon a time, you could take a mediocre product, slap on some glossy branding, line up a celebrity endorsement, and voila – you had a business. Marketing was a matter of the largest megaphone. You could drown out any complaints with sheer advertising volume and bulldoze your way to success. If you had a big enough budget, you could sell anything from questionably-built cars to sugary cereals that were basically dessert disguised as breakfast.

Today, that approach is simply going to torch you’re runway or budget. Thanks to social media, instant reviews, and viral marketing, a subpar product is sniffed out faster than you can say “deeply-discounted sales bin.” Users will roast you on Twitter, drown you in one-star reviews, and make TikToks mocking your product’s miserable usability.

The truth is, no amount of marketing muscle can save you if you don’t have Product-Market Fit. The internet is the great equalizer, and if your product isn’t genuinely solving a real problem, the market will call you out faster than ever.

But here’s the thing: When you do hit Product-Market Fit, it feels like pure magic. You’re not pushing your product uphill, you’re being dragged along by the momentum of desperate demand. And that’s the ultimate signal you’ve struck gold.

The term itself is most famously credited to investor Marc Andreessen, who described Product-Market Fit as “being in a good market with a product that can satisfy that market.” According to Andreessen, if you haven’t reached PMF, you’ll feel it in your bones: “Customers aren’t quite getting value… word of mouth isn’t spreading… usage isn’t growing that fast… the sales cycle takes too long.” But when you hit PMF, everything changes. Suddenly, “customers are buying the product just as fast as you can make it – or usage is growing just as fast as you can add more servers.” It’s chaos, but the kind you’d gladly pay money to have.

Andreessen wasn’t the only one to stress the life-or-death importance of PMF. His insight built on the wisdom of legends like Sequoia’s Don Valentine, who preached that market is everything, and Benchmark’s Andy Rachleff, who coined the harsh reality: “When a great team meets a lousy market, market wins. When a lousy team meets a great market, market wins. When a great team meets a great market, something special happens.”

In essence, lack of market demand is the #1 startup killer. And even the best product is doomed to fail if it’s designed for a market that doesn’t care. That’s why so much of modern startup methodology, from Steve Blank’s customer development framework to the Lean Startup movement, revolves around obsessively iterating toward Product-Market Fit.

But here’s the brutal truth: If you don’t find Product-Market Fit, nothing else matters. And even if you do find it, there’s no guarantee it’ll last. Competitors, shifting market dynamics, and evolving user needs can all erode what you thought was solid ground.

So how do you know you’ve truly reached Product-Market Fit? And if you haven’t, how do you get there before your runway runs out?

HOW TO KNOW WHEN YOU’VE FOUND IT 🤝 

Over the years, several powerful frameworks have emerged to help founders decode the mysterious moment when their product actually hits the mark. Here are the big four:

1. The Feel Test (Marc Andreessen):
Marc Andreessen’s definition of Product-Market Fit sounds almost mystical – like something you feel before you can even fully measure it. It’s when users are practically banging down your door, usage is skyrocketing, and customer acquisition feels more like crowd control than cold outreach. The feel test is a gut-check framework, something you instinctively know when you have it, and something you can just as easily identify when you don’t. Andreessen famously said, “If you’re still questioning whether you’ve achieved Product-Market Fit, you haven’t.” It’s a compelling, but risky, way to judge PMF.

2. The Sean Ellis 40% Rule:
For those who prefer data over vibes, Sean Ellis introduced a quantifiable way to measure PMF. His framework revolves around a simple but powerful survey question: “How would you feel if you could no longer use this product?” If at least 40% of respondents answer “Very disappointed,” you’re on the right track. This metric has become a go-to checkpoint for startups because it cuts through vanity metrics and measures genuine user dependence. Slack’s early success was confirmed through this method when a 2015 survey of 731 users found that about 51% of them would be “very disappointed” without the product. The beauty of Ellis’s method is that it forces founders to acknowledge whether their product is truly a must-have, rather than just a nice-to-have.

3. The Superhuman PMF Engine (Rahul Vohra):
What if you could engineer your way to Product-Market Fit? Rahul Vohra did exactly that with Superhuman, a premium email app designed to be absurdly fast. Inspired by Sean Ellis’s 40% rule, Vohra built a systematic process to continuously measure and improve PMF. Here’s how it worked:

• Surveying Users: He continuously surveyed early users to identify the most passionate fans – the 10-20% of users who were truly hooked.

• Iterative Improvement: Feedback from these users was used to optimize the product, while ignoring lukewarm responses from others.

• Testing Again: He repeated the process until the “very disappointed” score crossed the 40% threshold.

This approach turned PMF from a vague milestone into an actionable, repeatable process. It’s not just about finding PMF; it’s about building a machine to constantly refine and reinforce it.

4. Brian Balfour’s Growth Loops & Four Fits:
Brian Balfour takes the concept of Product-Market Fit even further by arguing that achieving PMF is only part of the battle. True success comes when you achieve several different types of “fits”:

• Product-Market Fit: The classic definition – does your product satisfy a real market need?

• Product-Channel Fit: Have you found a reliable way to reach your users?

• Channel-Model Fit: Can you acquire users in a financially sustainable way?

• Model-Market Fit: Is your revenue model aligned with what users are willing to pay?

Balfour emphasizes that if you want to build something truly scalable, you need to move beyond just satisfying a core user group. You need to create growth loops – systems where your existing users actively drive the acquisition of new users. Dropbox’s legendary referral program, which rewarded users with extra storage for inviting friends, is a textbook example of a successful growth loop built on solid Product-Market Fit.

OK, SO HOW THE HELL DO WE FIND IT? 🤔 

So, you know the frameworks. You’ve read the case studies. Now comes the tricky part – actually applying these concepts to figure out if you’ve hit Product-Market Fit or if you’re still fumbling around in the dark. Luckily, there are actionable steps you can take to turn the theory into reality.

Step 1: Test the Sean Ellis 40% Rule (and go deeper)
Conduct a survey asking users, “How would you feel if you could no longer use this product?” Focus on those who answer “Very disappointed.” If it’s 40% or higher, you’re on the right track. But don’t stop there – dig deeper by asking follow-up questions:

• What would you miss the most about the product?

• What type of people do you think would most benefit from the product?

• How can we improve the product for you?
  By analyzing patterns in these answers, you can refine your offering to better serve your most dedicated users.

Step 2: Build Your Own Superhuman PMF Engine
The genius of Rahul Vohra’s approach with Superhuman wasn’t just using the 40% rule – it was turning it into a continuous improvement process. Here’s how you can do the same:

• Segment Your Users: Identify your “core fans” – the small percentage of users who are genuinely enthusiastic about your product.

• Prioritize Feedback: Focus on enhancing features your core fans love and solving the biggest issues holding others back.

• Rinse and Repeat: Re-survey your users after each iteration to track your progress towards (or beyond) the 40% threshold.

This approach is a bit like sharpening a blade: each pass makes the product more effective, and before long, it’s cutting through the market like butter.

Step 3: Measure Your Retention Curve
Retention is the silent killer of startups. You can attract a flood of new users, but if they leave as quickly as they come, you’re back to square one. Instead of obsessing over vanity metrics like sign-ups or downloads, focus on cohort retention:

• Track how many users are still active after 1 week, 1 month, 3 months, etc.

• Healthy retention curves flatten out over time, meaning a consistent base of users is sticking around.

• If your curve keeps trending toward zero, you haven’t found PMF.

For consumer apps like Tinder, this flattening effect often happens when users fall in love with the product’s core experience. For enterprise SaaS tools, it’s usually when a product becomes indispensable to a team’s workflow.

Step 4: Leverage Word-of-Mouth and Virality
Product-Market Fit often shows itself through word-of-mouth growth. If people are spontaneously telling others about your product, that’s a signal you’re onto something. To measure this:

• Track organic acquisition: Are more than 50% of your new users coming from direct or organic traffic (rather than paid marketing)?

• Measure your viral coefficient: Are existing users consistently inviting new users?

• Ask “How did you hear about us?” It sounds almost too simple to work, but it does. This question cuts through the noise and tells you exactly which channels are truly memorable and effective in driving new users. You might discover a podcast shoutout or a customer’s tweet did more for your growth than months of paid ads.

• Monitor unsolicited press and social media mentions.

If growth feels like a runaway train rather than a car you’re pushing up a hill, you’re probably hitting Product-Market Fit.

Step 5: Rapidly Iterate and Test New Hypotheses
If you’re still struggling to find that magic moment, don’t just sit there and hope. Apply the Lean Startup approach of rapid testing and iteration.

• Launch Minimum Viable Products (MVPs): Test new features or approaches with the smallest, quickest version possible.

• Analyze What Works: If something shows promise, double down on it. If not, scrap it and try again.

• Stay Relentlessly Focused: The only thing that matters until you hit PMF is finding what works. Once you do, the game shifts to scaling it.

Potential Pitfalls to Avoid:

• Ignoring Negative Feedback: Don’t just focus on your core fans – understand why other users are lukewarm and see if their concerns are valid.

• Misinterpreting Growth Spikes: Don’t confuse short-term hype or promotional bumps for genuine Product-Market Fit.

• Obsessing Over Vanity Metrics: High downloads or sign-ups mean nothing if your retention curve looks like a ski slope.

Tools and Resources to Make It Easier:

• Survey Platforms: Typeform, SurveyMonkey, or Google Forms for running your 40% surveys.

• Analytics Tools: Mixpanel, Amplitude, or Heap for tracking retention and engagement.

• NPS Measurement Tools: Promoter.io or Qualaroo for capturing user satisfaction scores.

• User Feedback Tools: Hotjar, Pendo, or UserTesting for qualitative insights.

The beauty of these steps is that they work regardless of whether you’re a tiny startup or an established company trying to launch a new product. The common thread? Listen, measure, iterate, and repeat until the market is demanding your product faster than you can supply it.

A FEW DIRTY TRUTHS ABOUT PMF 🤔

It’s easy to romanticize Product-Market Fit as the ultimate milestone – a glorious moment where everything clicks, and success is just a matter of scaling up. But like most things in the startup world, the reality is messier, and sometimes downright disappointing.

Myth #1: Product-Market Fit Is Always Obvious
Everyone loves to talk about the “Aha!” moment – that magical point where everything falls into place, users are flocking to your product, and you can’t keep up with demand. But in truth, not every company gets the dramatic, Hollywood-style breakthrough. For many startups, Product-Market Fit is something they only recognize in hindsight after a series of gradual, compounding improvements.

Even within successful companies, team members might argue about whether PMF has truly been achieved. One group might point to rising user numbers, while another insists the growth is superficial, driven by temporary promotions rather than genuine market pull. If your team is debating PMF instead of high-fiving about it, the jury might still be out.

Myth #2: Product-Market Fit Is Permanent
Achieving PMF doesn’t mean you get to put your feet up and watch the money roll in forever. Markets evolve. Competitors swoop in with newer, shinier solutions. And user expectations keep climbing. Investor Brad Feld called the idea of permanent Product-Market Fit an “illusion.” He’s seen companies hit what they thought was stable PMF at $500k MRR, only to watch it slip away because they couldn’t adapt quickly enough.

Consider Instagram’s meteoric rise. Its clean, visual-sharing platform obliterated earlier photo-sharing apps like Hipstamatic and Flickr, even though those companies thought they had PMF locked down. A killer new product or shift in user behavior can quickly render yesterday’s fit obsolete.

Myth #3: Hype = Product-Market Fit
It’s tempting to confuse a sudden spike in interest with real PMF. The hype machine can be deceptive. Maybe you went viral on Product Hunt, got a glowing review from TechCrunch, or ran a killer marketing campaign. The sign-ups are flooding in. Investors are taking your calls. But here’s the rub: If those users aren’t sticking around or converting to paying customers, you’ve got a short-lived sugar rush, not sustainable growth.

For every Tinder or Stripe that found true PMF, there’s a cautionary tale like the app Color, which raised $40M in funding and generated tons of buzz, only to flop because the broader market simply didn’t want it. The key takeaway? If users aren’t begging to pay for your product after a free trial, you haven’t hit PMF.

Myth #4: A Small Loyal Audience Means You’ve Won
Sometimes, what looks like Product-Market Fit is just a really passionate niche audience. It’s great to have die-hard fans, but if there aren’t enough of them to support a viable business, you’re in trouble. Andy Rachleff makes a critical distinction between a “value hypothesis” (you’ve found something valuable to a small group) and a “growth hypothesis” (you can scale that value to a wider audience).

A small, loyal user base can be a fantastic starting point, but it’s not the finish line. You need to figure out if your product’s appeal can stretch beyond the early adopters or if you’re looking at a dead end.

Myth #5: The Product Is All That Matters
The phrase “Product-Market Fit” makes it sound like the product alone holds the magic. But distribution, timing, and pricing can be just as important. A killer product that no one knows about is as useful as a gold mine buried under the sea.

Brian Balfour argues that achieving Product-Market Fit also means nailing your go-to-market strategy. This involves product-channel fit (finding the right platforms to reach your audience), channel-model fit (ensuring your customer acquisition is financially viable), and model-market fit (aligning your pricing structure with what customers are willing to pay). Neglecting these areas can leave you feeling like you have a great product that nobody seems to want – when the real problem is that they just haven’t discovered it yet.

Myth #6: Product-Market Fit Is a One-and-Done Process
Here’s the kicker: Finding Product-Market Fit isn’t a finish line. It’s a continuously evolving target. As your company grows, the market shifts, and user needs change, you’ll likely need to rediscover and refine PMF over and over. The Lean Startup’s obsession with iteration and customer feedback is rooted in this reality – even when you think you’ve nailed it, you’re only one competitor or market trend away from falling behind.

How to Mitigate These Risks

• Stay Paranoid: Keep listening to your customers even when things are going well.

• Continuously Measure: Keep running those “How would you feel if you could no longer use this product?” surveys.

• Balance Quantitative and Qualitative Feedback: Numbers alone won’t tell you the full story.

• Adapt Relentlessly: Never assume you’ve “arrived.” Every product eventually needs to evolve.

The takeaway? Product-Market Fit isn’t a one-time event. It’s a process, and if you’re not actively trying to maintain it, you’re probably already losing it.

LET’S BRING THIS HOME/ TO WORK 🧑‍🏭 

So, we’ve covered a lot of ground. You now understand that Product-Market Fit isn’t just a catchy buzzword – it’s the absolute cornerstone of startup success. Without it, you’re pouring water into a bucket with a hole in the bottom. But with it, you’re building something so desirable that users are practically dragging it out of your hands.

But here’s the trick: Even if you achieve Product-Market Fit, you’re never really done. Markets shift. Competitors improve. User expectations evolve. The good news? If you get it right once, you’ve got the playbook for doing it again.

The question now is: What do you actually do with all this information? Here’s a step-by-step action plan, whether you’re a marketer trying to fine-tune your messaging or a founder on the verge of burnout.

1. Commit to Measuring Product-Market Fit Regularly:
Don’t wait until the company is on fire to check if you still have PMF. Make it a regular habit.

• Continuously run Sean Ellis-style surveys.

• Track your retention curve – is it flattening or trending downward?

• Monitor your viral coefficient – are your existing users actively bringing in new users?

• Keep asking “How did you hear about us?” to see which channels are truly driving memorable engagement.

2. Identify and Double Down on Your Core Fans:
Just like Rahul Vohra’s Superhuman strategy, don’t waste precious resources trying to please everyone.

• Segment your audience and identify your most passionate users.

• Interview them to understand why they love your product.

• Double down on enhancing the features they rave about and fixing the friction points that frustrate them.

3. Build Feedback Loops and Growth Engines:
Brian Balfour’s growth loops aren’t just a fancy concept – they’re your ticket to sustainable growth.

• Identify your product’s natural growth loops (e.g., referral programs, user-generated content, network effects).

• Design your product to actively encourage sharing, collaboration, or viral growth.

• Monitor and refine these loops relentlessly.

4. Don’t Fall for False Signals:
Don’t mistake hype, PR buzz, or paid acquisition spikes for real PMF.

• Focus on cohort retention and user satisfaction, not vanity metrics.

• Be brutal about cutting features or marketing efforts that don’t show real traction.

5. Continuously Iterate and Evolve:
Product-Market Fit isn’t permanent. As the market evolves, so must you.

• Regularly test new features, messaging, and distribution channels.

• Stay open to the idea of pivoting if your core users’ needs begin to shift.

• Remain paranoid. As soon as you think you’ve nailed it, someone else is probably figuring out how to do it better.

6. Balance Quantitative and Qualitative Feedback:

• Numbers are essential, but user stories and emotional feedback matter just as much.

• Listen to your superfans but also pay attention to the lukewarm feedback – sometimes that’s where your greatest insights lie.

Final Thought:

Achieving Product-Market Fit isn’t a destination – it’s an ongoing journey. The sooner you realise that, the better prepared you’ll be to continuously adapt, improve, and ultimately dominate your market.

Now, are you ready to stop guessing and start measuring? Because if you’re not relentlessly working toward Product-Market Fit, your competitors sure are.

If you enjoyed this edition, please forward it to a friend who’s looking to level-up their growth game - they’ll love you for it (and I will too) ⏭️ 💌

PS. When you’re ready here’s how I can help you:

1. Fractional CXO services: Need a top strategic product, marketing and digital transformation mind to grow your brand, but don’t want the hefty price tag? Fractional CXO services allow you to start growing revenue, before your grow your people costs. Limited slots available.

2. Events and Conference Host: Don’t get the guy who last week was MC’ing a carpet industry conference. If you’re in marketing, CX or digital I can help make your conference a memorable delight for your attendees.

Troy Muir | The Ladder